Encouragement or coercion

In Victoria, sentence indication schemes have evoked a range of attitudes from lawyers and the judiciary. Available in the Magistrates Court since 1992 without any legislative backing, the scheme was given a legislative footing and expanded to the higher courts as a pilot project in 2008 following a Sentencing Advisory Council report. In 2010, the council report on the pilot recommended continuation of the sentence indication scheme and the government implemented that recommendation by repealing the sunset provision that previously hung over the sentence indication clauses.

Despite this brief history of gradual acceptance of sentence indication processes, the higher Victorian courts have been generally cautious about sentence indication. They have cited concerns about judicial independence, the risk of plea bargaining and the involvement of the judge in an accused's plea decisions. Guariglia v R [2010] VSCA 343 is the latest example of this caution.